His Majesty the King, et al. v. B.F., et al.
B.F., a surgical nurse, had a child, E. In 2019, an interim family court ruling granted E.’s father supervised access, which B.F. resisted. At the time, B.F. was residing with her mother, I.F.
On June 12, 2019, a neighbour found B.F., I.F., and E., then 19 months old, in B.F.’s home. All three were unconscious in B.F.’s bedroom. First responders found five empty insulin pens at the scene, each of which originally contained many times the normal adult dose. There were nine visible injection marks on E.’s body and evidence that E. had resisted the injections; no injection marks were visible on B.F. or I.F. The first responders also located a handwritten letter at the scene that they characterized as a suicide note. Due to the quantity of insulin injected into her system, E. suffered serious and permanent brain and organ damage. She was diagnosed with cerebral palsy and spasticity and requires constant medical care. B.F. was arrested and charged with two counts of attempted murder by administering a noxious substance and two counts of aggravated assault.
The Crown’s theory at trial was that B.F. intended to kill E. in response to her estranged spouse obtaining access to the child. A jury convicted B.F. of the attempted murder of E. and I.F., and of the aggravated assault of E. The jury acquitted B.F. of the aggravated assault of I.F.
B.F. appealed her conviction and sentence to the Court of Appeal for Ontario. The conviction and sentence appeal in relation to the attempted murder of E. was dismissed.The conviction appeal in relation to the attempted murder of I.F. was allowed and a new trial ordered.
The Crown sought and was granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada (“SCC”). The Crown argues that the Court of Appeal’s findings were premised on a flawed understanding of causation for homicide, and that the Court’s reasoning led it to adopt a novel interpretation of the relationship between the offences of assisting suicide and homicide, which the SCC should reject.

